What is a gate review?

Gate reviews are vital checkpoints in project management, helping identify & address issues before they derail projects

In project management, gate reviews (also known as stage reviews or stage gates) are formal control points that act as decision gates throughout a project’s lifecycle. These scheduled checkpoints play an important role: to assess the project’s progress, identify and manage risks, and ultimately determine whether the project should be approved to move forward to the next stage. These are also known as project gates and act as a formal governance step to ensure that all required processes are completed and approved before moving to the next project phase.

Think of gate reviews as critical milestones where stakeholders come together to evaluate the project’s health. They provide a valuable opportunity to ensure the project is on track to meet its objectives, remains within budget and timeline constraints, and continues to be aligned with organisational goals. The project board and project manager play key roles in reviewing project stages and ensuring project goals are aligned with the business case.

A breakdown of the key elements of a gate review

Pre-defined Stages: Projects are typically divided into project phases or stages, with each phase  having specific deliverables and objectives. For each project phase, detailed plans and a project plan are developed to guide project tasks to completion and ensure clarity at every stage. Gate reviews are scheduled at the end of each stage or at key milestones within a stage.

Stakeholder Participation: Gate reviews involve a designated group of stakeholders, including project sponsors, key decision-makers, and project team members. Each stakeholder brings their unique perspective to the review process.

Review Criteria: Gate reviews are not simply progress reports. They involve a structured evaluation based on pre-defined criteria. These criteria may include project deliverables, budget adherence, risk management plans, and overall project viability. Reviewing the project's progress and completion of project tasks is essential to determine readiness for the next steps.

Go/No-Go Decisions: The outcome of a gate review is a critical decision point. Based on the evaluation, the stakeholders may decide to:

• Approve: Grant the project permission to proceed to the next stage.
• Hold: Pause the project and require corrective actions before proceeding.
• Recycle: Revisit the project scope, plans, or approach before continuing.
• Kill: Terminate the project if it is deemed no longer viable.

After each gate review, the following steps are determined to guide the project forward. In the last stage, the focus shifts to final deliverables and project closure.

Why gate reviews are important

Implementing gate reviews offers numerous advantages for project managers and stakeholders alike:

• Enhanced Project Control: Gate reviews provide a structured approach to monitoring project progress and ensuring alignment with initial objectives. ‍
• Proactive Risk Management: By identifying potential risks early on, gate reviews allow for timely mitigation strategies to be implemented. ‍
• Improved Decision-Making: The structured evaluation process and stakeholder involvement during gate reviews lead to well-informed decisions about the project's direction. ‍
• Increased Project Transparency: Gate reviews foster open communication and ensure all stakeholders are aware of the project's status and potential challenges.

Conclusion

Gate reviews are a cornerstone of effective project management. By incorporating these scheduled checkpoints into your project lifecycle, you can ensure projects stay on track, manage risks effectively, and ultimately achieve your desired outcomes.

‍